Shaw Local's weekly list of Will County property transfers for October 19 to 25 has a run of Plainfield sales that looks a lot like a builder's price sheet. 2210 Candlewood Drive sold for $359,900. 1605 Cascade Ridge Drive went for $405,000, 24220 Mill Creek Lane for $410,000 and 24902 W. Ambrose Road for $480,000. 24931 W. Blakely Drive topped the group at $516,000.
Now look at what Plainfield's active builders are asking for brand-new homes. D.R. Horton lists Playa Vista Townes from $349,990. Pulte lists single-family homes at Bronk Farm from $523,990. The cheapest new home and the most expensive starting price sit within about $10,000 of the low and high ends of that one week of resales.
New construction in Plainfield is no longer the pricier tier. At the starting price, a new home and a resale home are the same purchase. The differences show up after the starting price, in the options and lot premiums added to it, in who sets the mortgage terms and in the homes the village has already approved to come next.
The Two Price Ranges Overlap
Here is what the builders selling in Plainfield are advertising this month. These are snapshots from the builders' own pages, and builders change prices and inventory without notice.
| Community | Builder | Starting price | Size range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Playa Vista Townes | D.R. Horton | $349,990 | Varies by plan |
| Lockley Park townhomes | M/I Homes | $351,990 | 1,781 to 2,076 sq ft |
| Autumn Glen | Lennar | $354,994 to $429,495 | 1,717 to 2,079 sq ft |
| Greenbriar Freedom ranch homes | D.R. Horton | $399,990 | 1,660 to 1,956 sq ft |
| Playa Vista | D.R. Horton | $434,990 | 1,818 to 2,600 sq ft |
| Greenbriar | D.R. Horton | $475,990 | 1,970 to 3,044 sq ft |
| Bronk Farm | Pulte | $523,990 | 2,391 to 3,539 sq ft |
Bronk Farm's townhome section, which shows a starting price of $393,990, is listed as sold out.
Resales in the other weeks look the same. In Shaw Local's Sept. 7 to 13 list, Plainfield sales include 1913 Chestnut Grove Drive at $375,000 and 6102 Pheasant Ridge Drive at $431,700. The Oct. 12 to 18 list includes 2302 Irvine Lane at $490,000. In the Oct. 26 to Nov. 1 list, 3105 Twin Falls Drive sold for $463,500 and 25102 Presidential Avenue for $534,900. The Nov. 2 to 8 list has 1911 Chestnut Hill Road at $349,500 and 25543 W. Gateway Circle at $527,000.
That gives two ranges, roughly $350,000 to $525,000 for new homes and $349,500 to $534,900 for these recorded resales, nearly matching at both ends. If two products cost the same, a buyer is really comparing everything other than the price.
The County Numbers Point the Same Way
Plainfield spans two counties, and the Illinois REALTORS quarterly reports for each describe a market with plenty of choice for buyers.
In Will County's Q3 2026 report, the median sale price for July through September was $385,000, up 4.1% from the third quarter of 2025. Closed sales slipped 0.6% to 2,366, and inventory rose 2.5% to 1,492. Homes took a median 22 days to sell, one day longer than a year earlier. The single-family median for the quarter was $419,000, which falls between Greenbriar Freedom's and Playa Vista's starting prices.
Kendall County's Q3 2026 report shows supply growing faster than sales. Closed sales rose 15.4% to 659 for the quarter, while inventory jumped 30.9% to 470 homes. Median days on market went from 19 to 23. The single-family median held at $446,000, unchanged from a year earlier.
When prices hold flat while listings climb by almost a third, buyers have room. Resale sellers and builders are bidding for the same people, and they compete in different ways.
Builders Compete on the Mortgage, Resale Sellers on the Price
Builders' preferred tool right now is the interest rate. M/I Homes advertises a 3/2/1 buydown at Lockley Park, with a first-year fixed rate of 2.875% and a 6.03% APR through M/I Financial. The page shows no end date. D.R. Horton marks some quick move-in homes at Greenbriar, Greenbriar Freedom, Playa Vista and Playa Vista Townes with a "Special Interest Rate" tag. Lennar's Autumn Glen page links to a "Black Friday" limited-time deal without listing its terms on the page.
These incentives usually come through the builder's own lender, so the discount arrives in the loan rather than in the price. A buyer comparing a buydown at Lockley Park with a resale on Chestnut Hill Road is comparing a lower monthly payment for a few years against a lower price that lasts for the life of the loan. Which is worth more depends on how long the buyer stays and what rates do in the meantime. For a resale, the seller's room to cut the price is the main thing to negotiate, and that room grows as inventory builds.
The starting price on a builder's page is also where the price starts, not where it ends. Lot premiums, structural options and design upgrades get added from there. Lennar says on its Autumn Glen page that features and prices vary and that some features are optional. M/I's Lockley Park homes come with "professionally curated design packages," which settles the finishes but leaves the final contract price to the options a buyer picks. A resale's recorded price already includes whatever finishes, fencing and landscaping the house came with. A recorded resale price should be compared with the new home's price after options, not its starting price.
Monthly Dues and What They Pay For
Dues are the next thing that changes the real cost. M/I lists Lockley Park's HOA at $298 a month, and it says landscaping and exterior upkeep are handled for owners. Lennar lists approximate HOA fees of $200 for the Autumn Glen townhomes. These are figures from the builders' pages, and they can change. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm dues, rates and incentive terms for your own situation with the builder, your lender and your attorney before you sign.
Established subdivisions charge dues too, and the amenities those dues support are already built. AMG Management describes Wesmere as having a 10,000-square-foot clubhouse, three pools, parks, tot lots and sports courts. Grande Park has a clubhouse, pools, parks, walking paths and tennis and basketball courts. At Lockley Park, M/I says the green space, pocket parks and walking paths will "eventually surround" the neighborhood, with a community park in the center. At the same price, an established home comes with amenities you can use now, and a new home comes with amenities on the builder's schedule.
The Approved Supply Behind the Model Homes
The current model homes aren't the last ones coming. In September, the Plainfield Village Board approved Pulte's Bluestem, a 91-home subdivision on about 40 acres at the northeast corner of 119th Street and 248th Avenue. Shaw Local reported prices of $520,000 to perhaps $700,000 and that Pulte hoped to start in the spring.
Two older approvals carry more weight. In November 2025, the village approved Marquette Land Advisors' plan for 565 residences on about 36 acres at 24651 W. Lockport Street, made up of 528 multifamily units, including 264 townhouses, plus 37 single-family homes, according to Shaw Local's coverage. In March 2025, trustees reapproved Springbank Unit 3A for up to 156 detached homes on 54.6 acres west of Drauden Road and south of Allison Road, Patch reported.
Bluestem's reported price range starts just under Bronk Farm's current starting price and runs higher. The Wallin Woods-area plan is mostly attached housing, the same kind Playa Vista Townes and Lockley Park are selling now. Over the next few years, both new and established homes in the $350,000 to $525,000 range will face more new competition, which gives today's buyer more choices and means that whoever later sells a home bought now will be listing it next to newer ones.
Putting the Two Side by Side
Start with the price you would actually sign at. For a new home, that is the starting price plus the lot premium and the options you choose. For a resale, it is the negotiated price, set in a quarter when Kendall County inventory grew by almost a third. Next, put the builder's buydown against a price cut on the resale and work out each one over the years you plan to stay, since the buydown fades and the price cut doesn't. Then look at the dues and at whether the amenities they pay for already exist. Last, keep Bluestem, the Wallin Woods-area plan and Springbank's next phases in mind, because they will add more homes to the same price range.
For more on Plainfield itself, see our Plainfield neighborhood page, and if size is the open question, read Should You Upsize or Downsize in Plainfield? If you already own in Plainfield and plan to sell before buying, a home valuation shows where your house lands against these new-construction prices.
Weighing a model home in Plainfield against a resale a few streets away? Bring both to Alexa Mimi Wagner and let's talk through the price after options, the financing and the dues side by side. Let's Connect.